Turtles' Clam Consumption: A Tasty Treat Or A Tough Shell?

Turtles and clams are often mistaken to be related because they both have shells. However, they are two completely different creatures. Turtles are reptiles of the order Testudines, and clams are bivalve mollusks. While turtles are cold-blooded, clams have open circulatory systems, meaning their organs are surrounded by watery blood that contains oxygen and nutrients. Interestingly, some turtle owners have wondered whether clams can be kept in a turtle tank, either as food or to help filter the water. However, clams will not survive in a turtle tank because of the high levels of nitrogenous waste produced by turtles.

Turtles and clams are not related but share a shell

Turtles and clams are not closely related but do share a common feature: a shell. While turtles are part of the Testudines order, clams are soft-bodied mollusks. This classification places them in the Bivalvia order. Despite their differences, these two creatures have a shell in common, which serves as protection for their bodies.

The shells of turtles and clams are made of different materials. A turtle's shell is composed of keratin, the same substance that makes up human fingernails. On the other hand, clams have shells made of calcium carbonate, which is also the main mineral found in eggshells. The calcium carbonate binds to proteins secreted by the clam's mantle, the outermost layer of tissue that connects the clam to its shell.

The process of shell formation differs between turtles and clams. In clams, specialized cells in the mantle build the shell using proteins and minerals. These proteins create a framework that provides support for the growing shell and determine which minerals are used in specific parts. As a result, clam shells have three layers, each with a distinct composition and function.

In contrast, a turtle's shell is not built by its body but is rather a product of the keratin that the turtle produces. The shell grows as the turtle does, and the rate of growth can pose challenges when attempting to attach tracking devices for research purposes. The shell also serves as a protective covering, shielding the turtle's body.

While turtles and clams are not closely related in terms of species, they do share the common feature of a shell. These shells provide protection and are essential for the survival of both creatures. The shells differ in composition, with clamshells containing calcium carbonate and proteins, while turtles have shells made of keratin.

Clams cannot survive in a turtle tank

Clams are beautiful, complex creatures with unique needs. Unfortunately, they cannot survive in a turtle tank. Here are several reasons why:

Water Quality

Turtles produce a lot of waste, which can dramatically raise ammonia and nitrate levels in the water. Clams require pristine water quality, especially when it comes to nitrogenous waste products. High levels of ammonia can be deadly to clams. While clams can tolerate "dirty" water filled with microorganisms that they feed on, they cannot survive in water contaminated with uneaten turtle food or turtle waste.

Water Flow

Clams require very good water flow, which can be challenging to achieve in a turtle tank. In their natural habitat, clams are used to strong currents and waves. While they can adapt to linear flow, it must be set up correctly to ensure the water flow does not cause the clam's mantle to fold upwards or retract. Proper water flow is essential for the clam's survival.

Filtration

Clams are filter feeders, which means they acquire nutrients by filtering the water around them. However, in a turtle tank, they are more likely to consume uneaten food or waste, which can be harmful to them. Additionally, turtles tend to dig, and if a clam is dug out and exposed in open turtle water, it is unlikely to survive.

Space Constraints

Clams need ample space to grow and thrive. Some species can reach sizes of up to 24 inches in diameter and require enough space to triple in size within a year. A turtle tank may not provide the necessary space for clams to grow and move around until they find a suitable spot to attach, potentially leading to stress and health issues.

In conclusion, while clams and turtles may coexist in the wild, the specific needs of clams make it challenging for them to survive in a turtle tank. It is essential to provide the proper environment and conditions for each species to ensure their health and well-being.

Turtles can eat clams, but they should be fresh

Turtles can eat clams, but it is important to ensure that the clams are fresh and not wild, as wild clams may carry parasites or diseases that could harm your turtle. It is also important to remove the shell before feeding clams to turtles.

The diet of a turtle depends on its species and age. For example, green sea turtles are typically omnivores when they are young, eating a mix of fish, invertebrates, and leafy greens. As they grow older, they tend to become herbivores, eating mostly plants like seagrass and algae. On the other hand, loggerhead and Kemp's ridley sea turtles share similar diets and are known to eat invertebrates such as clams, shrimp, crabs, mussels, fish, and squid.

It is worth noting that turtles may accidentally consume plastic marine debris and other items that they mistake for food in the ocean. Therefore, it is important to reduce single-use plastic and properly dispose of trash to protect sea turtles and other marine animals.

Clams can be used to filter dirty water

Clams are natural water purifiers and can be used to filter dirty water. They feed by creating currents that move water in and out of their bodies. Tiny hair-like structures, called cilia, cover their gills and pump water through their bodies, drawing it in through an incurrent siphon. Suspended particles in the water are then captured by the gills and moved to the mouth for ingestion. The cleared water is then ejected through an excurrent siphon.

A single littleneck-sized clam can filter 4.5 gallons of seawater per day. Clams are filter feeders, and in the process of feeding, they filter phytoplankton (microscopic algae or plants), microorganisms, and detritus. This improves water clarity by reducing sediment loads and turbidity, and removing excess nutrients from inshore coastal waters. Clearer water allows more sunlight to penetrate, aiding the growth of important seagrasses and increasing oxygen levels. Clams may also prevent harmful algal blooms.

Clams are also beneficial in the cycling of nutrients, including nitrogen. They do not absorb nitrogen directly from their environment but instead feed on naturally-occurring phytoplankton, which use dissolved inorganic nitrogen to grow. Clams incorporate the nitrogen from their food into their tissues and shells. When clams are harvested, the accumulated nitrogen is removed from the water. Clams also release nitrogenous waste (urine) that can be used by phytoplankton as a source of nitrogen. In addition, some of the filtered nitrogen is deposited as feces and pseudofeces (rejected food particles), which are decomposed by bacteria and transformed into other forms of nitrogen.

Clams are not just filter feeders, they also sequester carbon from the atmosphere. A single littleneck-sized clam can store 2.76 grams of atmospheric carbon. Clams convert carbon into calcium carbonate shell material. The carbonate used by clams is primarily derived from atmospheric carbon dioxide dissolved in seawater. Thus, the shells of cultured clams provide a long-term carbon sink. Clams not only store carbon in their shells and tissues but also process it while they are growing. Just like other animals, they produce carbon dioxide as a waste product of respiration.

The value of clams in filtering and purifying water has been recognized by researchers and communities alike. A University of Florida study from 2015 examined the environmentally beneficial ecosystem services of clam farming, including water filtration, nitrogen removal, and carbon storage. The results demonstrated the unique sustainability of Florida hard clam aquaculture. Similarly, towns in Cape Cod are considering seeding and growing shellfish as a way to reduce nitrogen levels in coastal waters. Shellfish provide a cheaper and faster alternative to building sewers and wastewater treatment systems, which can be incredibly costly.

While clams are effective in filtering and purifying water, they are not suitable for use in turtle tanks. Turtles produce a lot of waste, and the high levels of ammonia and nitrates in their tanks can be deadly for clams.

Clams are not suitable food for all turtles

Additionally, clams have very different living requirements from turtles. Clams require pristine water in terms of nitrogenous waste products, but they thrive in water filled with lots of microorganisms to feed on. In contrast, turtles produce a lot of waste, and their water needs to be carefully filtered and aerated. Due to their high metabolic rates, some species of turtles have higher body temperatures than the water they are surrounded by. This means that the water in a turtle tank is often too dirty for clams to survive, and they will not be able to contribute to filtration as hoped.

Furthermore, clams will not be able to avoid being eaten by turtles. While clams protect themselves by clamping up and withdrawing into their shell when they feel threatened, turtles are persistent and will break through the shell to get to the clam inside.

Therefore, while clams may be a suitable food source for some turtle species, they are not a practical addition to a turtle tank and may even pose risks to your turtle's health if sourced from the wild.

Frequently asked questions