Shelters And Cat Euthanasia: Exploring The Reality

The topic of whether shelters kill cats is a highly debated and complex issue. While there is a lack of recent national statistics on shelter euthanasia rates in the United States, older studies indicate that euthanasia in animal shelters is the leading documented cause of death for cats, with 72% of cats entering these facilities being killed. This has led to a push for no-kill policies and legislation, with states like California aiming to end the euthanasia of adoptable pets and improve adoption rates. However, critics argue that no-kill policies can have unintended consequences, such as hoarding or abuse, and that the focus should be on addressing the root cause of the problem, which is the high animal birth rate. The issue remains a challenging and emotional one, with strong opinions on both sides.

Why do shelters euthanize cats?

Shelters may euthanize cats due to several reasons, including overcrowding, sickness, aggression, injury, or other health issues. Euthanasia may also be chosen over releasing cats back into the wild that shelters do not have the resources to neuter, as this could contribute to overpopulation.

In 1997, around 64% of animals that entered shelters were euthanized, which amounted to approximately 2.7 million animals across 1,000 shelters. More cats are euthanized than dogs, with 56% of dogs and 71% of cats in shelters being put down. Cats are more likely to be euthanized than dogs because they are more likely to enter a shelter without any owner identification, making it difficult to reunite them with their owners. Only 15% of dogs and 2% of cats in shelters without identification are reunited with their families.

The decision to euthanize an animal is never easy, and shelter workers try to avoid it as much as possible. They may reach out to multiple rescues to try to get animals pulled from the shelter before euthanasia becomes necessary. Additionally, some shelters have higher adoption rates than the state average, and some states are working towards becoming "no-kill states," aiming to end the killing of healthy animals in shelters.

To reduce euthanasia rates, some organizations advocate for the sterilization of all dogs and cats before they leave the shelter, as well as the establishment of low-cost spay/neuter clinics. Proper identification of pets, such as microchipping, can also increase the chances of reuniting lost pets with their owners and reduce the need for euthanasia.

How many cats are killed in shelters?

It is difficult to determine the exact number of cats that are killed in shelters due to a lack of standardised reporting requirements and inconsistent data. However, it is estimated that millions of cats are killed in shelters annually, with cats entering shelters facing three possible outcomes: adoption, reunion with their owners, or euthanasia.

In 1997, approximately 2.7 million animals were euthanised in 1,000 shelters, with 71% of cats that entered these shelters being euthanised. This is often due to overcrowding, illness, aggression, or injury. Cats are more likely to be euthanised than dogs because they are less likely to enter a shelter with owner identification, with only 2% of cats being reunited with their owners compared to 15.8% of dogs.

The leading cause of death for cats in the United States is euthanasia in animal control pounds and shelters. According to the most comprehensive study, 72% of cats entering these facilities are killed, 23% are adopted, and only 2% are reunited with their owners. These high euthanasia rates have sparked efforts to transition shelters to "no-kill" status, with states like California aiming to become a "no-kill state" by ensuring that no healthy or treatable animal is killed due to lack of space.

Nonprofits, research veterinarians, and experts agree that too many cats are killed in pounds and shelters, and efforts are being made to reduce euthanasia rates through sterilisation programs, microchipping, and increased adoption initiatives.

What are the alternatives to killing cats in shelters?

Cats and other pets are often surrendered to shelters due to financial reasons, death, divorce, housing restrictions, health issues, or other factors beyond their owner's control. Before surrendering your cat to a shelter, consider alternatives that could help keep your pet out of the shelter and save its life.

One alternative is to use a home-to-home pet adoption system, such as Get Your Pet, that connects people who need to rehome their pet directly with people looking to adopt. This eliminates the "middleman" and gives owners more control over their pet's fate. Additionally, some shelters, such as No-Kill Los Angeles, have a screening system to determine whether a pet is a suitable candidate for adoption. If your cat is healthy and well-behaved, it may be accepted into a no-kill shelter, relieving the load on other shelters.

If you are considering surrendering your cat due to a temporary issue, such as financial hardship or housing restrictions, it may be worth exploring temporary solutions. For example, you could ask a friend or family member to foster your cat until your situation improves. You could also contact local rescue groups or shelters and ask about foster care programs, as these can provide a temporary home for your cat while keeping them out of the shelter system.

Another alternative is to work with your local shelter to improve your cat's chances of adoption. Many shelters are happy to have volunteers help with walking, cleaning, feeding, and marketing. Good marketing can increase a cat's chances of adoption, so consider offering your skills as a photographer to help shelters take appealing pictures of their cats. You can also advocate for policies and laws that support no-kill shelters and reduce the number of cats euthanized. For example, support laws that require shelters to microchip cats before releasing them for adoption, as this increases the chances of reuniting lost cats with their owners.

What is the impact of no-kill policies on cats in shelters?

The impact of no-kill policies on cats in shelters is a complex issue with a range of consequences. No-kill policies aim to save all healthy and treatable cats from unnecessary euthanasia, and this has led to a significant increase in adoption numbers over the last decade. This, in turn, has helped shelters gain more funding, enabling them to build larger facilities, hire more staff, and purchase better medical equipment.

However, the no-kill movement has also had some unintended negative consequences. Shelters, particularly those in under-resourced communities, may struggle to provide adequate care for all the cats they take in, leading to psychological deterioration in the animals. Cats can become withdrawn, depressed, anxious, or aggressive, and this can lead to behavioural issues that make them less likely to be adopted. The pressure to avoid euthanasia at all costs can also lead to cats being placed with unsuitable owners or hoarders, resulting in abuse or neglect.

Another issue is that no-kill policies can divert resources from addressing the root causes of cat overpopulation, such as the runaway animal birth rate. While no-kill shelters focus on saving individual cats, they may not be able to provide the necessary support to address the broader issue of cat homelessness. This can result in a constant influx of cats into shelters, which further stretches their resources.

Overall, the impact of no-kill policies on cats in shelters has been both positive and negative. While these policies have increased adoption rates and improved shelter conditions, they have also led to challenges in providing adequate care for all cats and addressing the underlying causes of cat overpopulation. Ultimately, the success of no-kill policies depends on having sufficient resources and community support to care for and rehome cats while also addressing the root causes of cat homelessness.

How can people help reduce cat deaths in shelters?

Euthanasia in animal control pounds and shelters is the leading documented cause of death for cats in the US. A 1997 study found that 71% of cats in shelters were euthanized, with more recent studies showing a slight improvement, with 66% of cats in shelters being killed.

To reduce cat deaths in shelters, people can:

• Support and volunteer at local shelters: This includes walking dogs, helping with cleaning, feeding kittens, and marketing. People with specific skills, such as photography, can also offer their services to help promote animals for adoption.
• Advocate for and support legislation that aims to reduce companion animal deaths in shelters: This includes supporting bills that cap adoption fees, require sterilization of adopted animals, and prohibit pet stores from charging fees to display adoptable animals.
• Promote responsible pet ownership: This includes encouraging spaying and neutering of pets to reduce the number of unwanted animals, as well as ensuring that pets wear proper identification, such as microchips and tags, to increase the chances of reuniting lost pets with their owners.
• Address the root cause of the problem: Instead of focusing solely on finding homes for needy cats, people should also work to address the runaway animal birth rate, which is the source of the problem. This includes supporting low-cost spay/neuter clinics and promoting responsible breeding practices to reduce the number of unwanted animals.
• Provide steady companionship, affection, and stimulation to shelter cats: Cats in shelters can deteriorate psychologically and become withdrawn, depressed, or anxious if they do not receive adequate attention and stimulation. Volunteers can help by spending time with the cats, playing with them, and providing enrichment activities.

Frequently asked questions