Shooting Turtles: Is It Ethical Or Legal?

Shooting turtles is a controversial topic. While some people find it fun, others consider it unethical and question the motivation behind it. Some people shoot turtles because they believe the turtles are eating their fish and fish eggs. However, others argue that turtles are mostly vegetarian and will not eat live fish. There are also safety concerns when shooting near water, as bullets may deflect off turtle shells or ricochet off the water, endangering nearby people and property.

Is it legal to hunt with suppressors in Oklahoma?

In Oklahoma, it is legal to hunt with suppressors on both private and public lands. According to the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife Conservation, hunters are permitted to use legally acquired and possessed suppressors when hunting game animals, game birds, or non-game birds.

The relevant legislation concerning the use of suppressors while hunting in Oklahoma is outlined in Okla. Stat. tit. 29, § 5-201(A)(5). This law permits the use of suppressors for hunting, provided they are legally obtained and possessed.

It is important to note that while suppressor ownership and use for hunting is legal in Oklahoma, there may be additional regulations and requirements that need to be followed. These can include purchasing from licensed dealers, completing the necessary paperwork, and adhering to specific guidelines for storage and transportation.

Additionally, it is worth mentioning that the laws regarding suppressors and their use in hunting can change over time. Therefore, it is always advisable to refer to the most up-to-date information and consult with relevant authorities or experts before acquiring or using a suppressor for hunting in Oklahoma.

What guns are suitable for shooting turtles?

Shooting turtles is a popular pastime for some, and there are various guns that are suitable for the activity. However, it is important to be mindful of safety considerations, such as the risk of ricochets when shooting near water.

One option for shooting turtles is a *.22 rifle*, which has been used by several individuals. However, this may not be suitable if you have close neighbours due to the loud gun noises. In this case, you could consider using *.22 LR sub-sonic ammo*, which would be quieter than standard or high-velocity loads. Another option to reduce noise is to use a suppressor, although hunting with suppressors may be illegal in certain states.

If you are looking for a quieter option, a pellet gun with flat nose pellets could be a good choice. Flat nose pellets don't skip on the water as much as round or pointed pellets. However, keep in mind that most bullets will bounce off the water, so you need to be careful not to accidentally shoot towards your neighbours or their property.

For those who want to avoid using guns altogether, a floating turtle trap can be an effective alternative. This allows you to capture the turtles without the risk of ricochets or disturbing your neighbours.

What are the safety considerations when shooting near water?

Shooting near water comes with a unique set of risks and safety considerations that all shooters should be aware of. Here are some key points to keep in mind:

• Bullet Skipping and Ricochet: One of the biggest dangers of shooting near water is the risk of bullet skipping or ricochet. Bullets striking the water at a shallow angle can skip across the surface, like a stone, and travel in unpredictable directions. This can result in stray bullets hitting unintended targets, including people, property, or wildlife. Always ensure that the area beyond the water is clear of any potential hazards.
• Backstop: When shooting near water, it is crucial to have a safe backstop that can stop and contain bullets. The backstop should be larger than your target and made of materials that will not cause ricochets. Avoid shooting at targets placed on the ground, as bullets tend to ricochet upward and can travel long distances.
• Firearm Handling: Always follow basic firearm safety rules. Never handle firearms if someone is downrange, and always keep the weapon pointed in a safe direction. Be mindful of your surroundings, including nearby homes, livestock, or neighbours, and avoid creating unnecessary noise or disturbances.
• Specialised Ammunition: Certain types of ammunition, such as flat nose pellets, are less likely to skip on water. Consider using specialised ammunition that is designed for shooting near water to minimise the risk of ricochet.
• Hearing Protection for Animals: The noise from firearms can easily damage an animal's sensitive hearing. Keep pets and hunting dogs at a safe distance, at least 50 yards away from rifles or handguns, to protect their hearing.
• Personal Protective Equipment: Always wear proper hearing and eye protection when shooting. This includes both earplugs and earmuffs for your ears and side protection for your eyes.
• Alcohol and Drugs: Never consume alcohol or drugs before or during shooting. These substances can impair your judgment and safe-handling abilities, increasing the risk of accidents.
• Hygiene: Wash your hands and face after shooting to prevent the ingestion of lead or other chemical residues from firearms or ammunition. This is especially important before eating, drinking, or smoking.

Do turtles eat fish?

While some turtles are strictly vegetarian, others are omnivores or carnivores, meaning they eat a combination of animal protein and vegetables or primarily animal protein, respectively.

Some turtles, such as the spiny soft-shell turtle, are considered carnivorous and eat animal protein, including live prey such as feeder fish (goldfish, guppies, bait minnows, and smelt), insects, and dead fish. However, dead fish should be removed from the aquarium immediately to prevent water fouling and increased bacteria.

Most semiaquatic and aquatic turtles, such as red-eared sliders, painted turtles, and pond turtles, are omnivores. While they may eat some animal protein, their diet consists mostly of plant material, including dark, leafy greens and other vegetables.

Therefore, it is safe to say that some turtles do eat fish, especially those that are carnivorous or omnivorous. However, it is important to note that different species of turtles have different dietary needs, and it is essential to research the specific needs of your turtle based on its species.

In terms of shooting turtles, while it is not recommended and may be illegal in some places, there are accounts of people shooting turtles with various firearms, such as rifles and shotguns. However, it is important to consider safety and the potential for ricochets when shooting near water.

Is it ethical to shoot turtles?

Shooting turtles is a topic that has been discussed at length on online forums, with varying opinions on the ethics of the practice. Some people consider it fun and a way to pass the time, while others view it as cruel and unnecessary. There are also concerns about the impact of shooting turtles on the ecosystem, particularly if the turtles are an invasive species.

Shooting turtles for fun is generally seen as unethical by many people. One forum user stated that they "don't understand the wanton killing of turtles" and find it "creepy". Another person commented that they "will internally judge people that do so". This sentiment was echoed by several other users who view shooting turtles as cruel and unnecessary, especially if it is done purely for entertainment.

On the other hand, some people argue that shooting turtles can be justified in certain situations. For example, if the turtles are considered a nuisance or are perceived to be causing harm to the environment, some may see culling as a necessary evil. In particular, some fishers believe that turtles eat their fish and fish eggs and, therefore, shooting turtles could help protect their catch. However, this belief has been contested by others who claim that turtles are mostly vegetarian and will not eat live fish.

One forum user suggested that, rather than shooting turtles, it is better to let nature take its course and allow natural predators, such as alligators, to thin out the turtle population. This approach would avoid the ethical dilemma of shooting turtles while still addressing any potential issues caused by their presence.

Overall, the ethics of shooting turtles is a complex issue that depends on various factors, including personal beliefs, cultural norms, and the potential impact on the environment. It is important to consider the potential consequences and respect different viewpoints when discussing this topic.

Frequently asked questions