Betta-Guppy Tank: A Good Mix?

Male betta fish and female guppies can sometimes live together, but it's a risky combination. Male bettas are known for their aggression towards other fish, especially other male bettas. Guppies also have colourful, flowing tails, so male bettas often confuse them for other male bettas, leading to aggression. This combination is generally not recommended.

Male betta and female guppies may not be a good combination

Although it is possible to keep male betta fish and female guppies together in the same tank, it is not always advisable due to several factors that can increase the risk of aggression and territorial behaviour.

Male Betta Aggression

Male betta fish are known for their aggression towards other fish, especially other male bettas. This aggression may be directed towards female guppies if the male betta perceives them as a threat or competitor. Male bettas may attack female guppies, leading to stress and potential harm.

Mistaken Identity

Guppies, especially male guppies, have colourful, flowing tails that resemble those of male bettas. Male bettas may confuse female guppies for other male bettas, triggering their aggressive behaviour. Additionally, male guppies may mistake female bettas for female guppies and constantly pester them for breeding, causing stress and potentially leading to an attack.

Territorial Behaviour

Betta fish are highly territorial and require ample space to establish their territory. In a tank with guppies, bettas may become territorial and aggressive towards the guppies, especially if they feel their space is being invaded.

Feeding Competition

Guppies tend to be greedy eaters and may quickly gobble up food, leaving little to no food for the betta fish. This can lead to competition for food and potentially cause stress and aggression between the two species.

Fin Nipping

Guppies are known for their playful nature and tendency to nip at the fins of other fish. While this may not be done out of aggression, it can cause stress and injury to the betta fish.

Recommendations

If you decide to keep male betta fish and female guppies together, it is important to take several precautions. Provide a spacious tank with ample hiding places and plants to reduce stress and provide escape routes. Monitor the behaviour of the fish closely, especially during the initial introduction period. Be prepared to separate the fish if signs of aggression or fin nipping occur. Additionally, consider keeping female bettas with female guppies, as this combination is generally considered the safest and least aggressive option.

Male bettas are extremely aggressive

Male bettas are known to be hostile towards other fish species as well, including female bettas. They mistake colourful, flowing-tailed fish like guppies for competitors or potential mates, leading to aggressive behaviour. Male guppies, with their bright colours and flowing tails, often become targets of male betta aggression. Even female guppies, which are duller in colour, may be pursued incessantly for breeding, causing stress for the female guppy and potentially leading to her lashing out.

The combination of male bettas and male guppies is not recommended due to the high likelihood of aggression. While male bettas and female guppies can sometimes be housed together, it carries a high risk. The safest combination is female bettas and female guppies, as female bettas are generally less aggressive than their male counterparts.

To reduce aggression in male bettas, it is crucial to provide them with ample space and hiding places. A larger tank allows them to establish their own territory and reduces the chances of conflict. Additionally, introducing fish slowly and cautiously, providing tank dividers, and monitoring for signs of aggression are important steps to take when housing male bettas with other fish.

Female bettas and female guppies are the best combination

Combining female bettas and female guppies is the safest option if you want to keep these two species together. Female bettas are generally less aggressive than males, and female guppies are unlikely to trigger aggression in female bettas.

Male bettas are highly aggressive and territorial, and they can be very hostile towards other male fish, especially those with colourful, flowing tails, such as male guppies. Male bettas will often mistake male guppies for rivals and will attack them.

Female bettas are still aggressive, but they won't be as aggressive as males. They are faster than the males, but they are less likely to be territorial. Female guppies are duller in colour than male guppies, so they are less likely to trigger aggression in female bettas.

However, female bettas may mistake female guppies for "sorority sisters" and may bully them to establish a pecking order. To avoid this, make sure your tank is big enough for both species to have their own space and to avoid overcrowding. A 10-gallon tank is the minimum size for one betta and three guppies, and you should add an extra five gallons for every three guppies. It's also important to provide hiding places and plants in the tank, as these will give your fish somewhere to go if they feel threatened.

Both bettas and guppies need similar water conditions and temperatures, so they can live together in this respect. Bettas need a pH of 7 and a temperature between 78-80°F, while guppies need a pH of 6.8-7.8 and a temperature between 74-82°F.

Bettas and guppies also have similar dietary requirements, but you will need to manage their feeding schedules to prevent competition. Guppies are omnivores and need to eat more plant matter, while bettas are carnivores and need more protein.

In conclusion, female bettas and female guppies are the best combination for cohabitation. While there are still risks and challenges to be aware of, this combination is the safest option and will give you the best chance of a harmonious tank.

Male guppies are brightly coloured with flowing tails

Male guppies are known for their bright, vibrant colours and flowing, colourful tails. These colours and patterns are used to attract female guppies for breeding. In contrast, female guppies have duller, more subdued colouring, usually in pale grey or silver.

The male guppy's tail is large and colourful, while the female's is shorter and less wide. Male guppies have long, pointed anal fins, while female guppies have shorter, triangular anal fins.

The male guppy's colouring is not just for show or to attract a mate. The bright, vibrant colours are also an adaptive strategy, used to ward off rivals. Male guppies are territorial and aggressive, and their colouring is used to signal to other males.

Because of their bright colours and flowing tails, male guppies can trigger aggression in male betta fish, who may mistake them for competitors. This can lead to a hostile environment and even the death of the guppies.

Therefore, while it is possible to house male guppies with female betta fish, it is not recommended to keep them with male bettas.

Male guppies and female bettas may not be a good combination

Although it is possible to keep guppies and betta fish in the same tank, there are a number of factors to consider, including the sex of the fish, their dietary requirements, and the size of the tank.

Aggression and Territoriality

Male betta fish are known for their aggression, particularly towards other male bettas. Male guppies can also be aggressive towards other male guppies when competing for breeding rights. As such, a combination of male bettas and male guppies is not recommended.

Male bettas can also be aggressive towards female guppies, especially if they have colourful tails, as they may be mistaken for male bettas. This could lead to the male betta pursuing the female guppy incessantly for breeding or attacking her.

Female bettas can also be aggressive towards male guppies, as the male guppies may mistake them for female guppies and attempt to breed with them. This could lead to stress for the female betta and cause her to lash out at the male guppy.

Dietary Requirements

Bettas and guppies have different dietary requirements. Bettas require a high-protein, meat-based diet and do not eat vegetables, while guppies are omnivores and require both meat and vegetables. Guppies are also known to be greedy and eat quickly, which could result in the betta not receiving enough food.

Tank Size

Bettas require a lot of space, as they are used to swimming in rice paddies and floodplains. A tank that is too small can lead to health problems for the betta. Guppies also require their own space and are schooling fish, so they should be kept in a group of at least 3-5 individuals. For this reason, a large tank is necessary if you plan to keep bettas and guppies together.

Frequently asked questions