Siamese Fighters: Guppies In Disguise?

Whether or not Siamese fighting fish and guppies can be kept together is a highly debated topic among fish enthusiasts. Some people claim that it is not recommended to keep them together, as Siamese fighting fish may mistake guppies for their own kind and attack them. Additionally, guppies can be quite nippy, and may harass or even kill a Siamese fighting fish. However, others claim that it depends on the personality of the Siamese fighting fish, and some people have had success keeping the two species together without issues. In general, it is advised to have a backup tank in case aggression occurs or the fish need to be separated.

Siamese fighting fish and guppies can sometimes coexist if the fighting fish has a non-aggressive personality

While it is generally not recommended to keep Siamese fighting fish (Betta fish) and guppies together, it is possible for the two species to coexist if the Betta has a non-aggressive personality.

Bettas are extremely territorial and aggressive, especially the males, who are constantly fighting other males for dominance and territory. Guppies, on the other hand, are generally docile and live in schools. However, male guppies can become territorial and protective of their females, and guppies are notorious for fin-nipping, which can cause stress and injury to their tank mates.

Due to their similarities in appearance, with both having colourful and long fins and tails, Bettas may mistake guppies for competitors and become aggressive. Bettas are also slower swimmers than guppies, and their long, flowing fins can make it difficult for them to escape aggressive guppies.

However, some aquarists have reported success in keeping the two species together, provided that certain conditions are met. It is recommended to have a large tank, preferably 15-20 gallons or more, to provide enough space for both species to establish their own territories. The tank should also have plenty of hiding places and plants to reduce aggression and provide escape for threatened fish.

When selecting the fish, it is important to choose guppies and Bettas that are relatively peaceful. Younger Bettas that have not yet established their dominance are more likely to get along with guppies. It is also recommended to introduce the guppies to the tank first and then add the Betta, as Bettas are fiercely territorial and may see new fish as a threat.

Even with these precautions, there is still a chance that the Bettas and guppies might not get along. Therefore, it is important to monitor their behaviour closely, especially in the beginning, and be prepared to separate them if necessary.

Guppies can be aggressive and may attack Siamese fighting fish

Guppies are generally peaceful, social fish that are often kept in community aquariums. However, they can become aggressive and territorial if certain conditions are not met. For example, guppies can become aggressive when they are in survival mode, when their tank is overcrowded, or during mating season.

In some cases, guppies may display aggressive behaviour towards other species of fish, including Siamese fighting fish. While Siamese fighting fish are known to attack guppies, mistaking them for one of their own, guppies can also be the aggressors in this relationship. This is especially true if the guppies are male, as they may perceive the flowing tails of Siamese fighting fish as a sign of competition and attempt to establish their dominance.

Several factors can contribute to guppies becoming aggressive. One reason may be the introduction of new tank mates, which can cause guppies to gang up on the newcomer. Additionally, an overcrowded tank or a small group size can lead to stress and aggression in guppies. Guppies need their own personal space to thrive, and if they feel cramped, they may resort to aggressive behaviour to express their frustration.

Another factor that can trigger aggression in guppies is improper water conditions. If the water parameters are not optimal, guppies may become stressed and more prone to aggressive behaviour. High levels of ammonia, nitrate, or nitrites in the water can further exacerbate this issue.

It is worth noting that not all guppies will display aggressive behaviour towards Siamese fighting fish. Some guppies may be peaceful and get along just fine with their tank mates. However, if you notice any signs of aggression, such as injured fins or constant hiding, it is important to take action to protect the well-being of all the fish in the tank.

To mitigate aggression in guppies, it is recommended to maintain proper water conditions, provide enough hiding places, and ensure there is enough food for all the fish. If one particular guppy is consistently displaying aggressive behaviour, removing it from the tank may be necessary to ensure the safety of the other fish.

Siamese fighting fish may attack guppies if they have long, flowing tails, mistaking them for another fighting fish

Siamese fighting fish, also known as bettas, have a reputation for aggression towards other fish, including guppies. This is particularly true if the guppies have long, flowing tails, as the bettas may mistake them for another fighting fish.

Bettas are territorial and will fight to protect their space. They are also attracted to bright, colourful fish, which can make guppies a target. While some sources claim that bettas and guppies should never be kept together, others suggest that it depends on the individual personality of the betta. Some bettas may coexist peacefully with guppies, while others will attack and even kill them.

In addition, guppies can also be aggressive and may nip at the fins of bettas, causing injury or stress. Therefore, it is generally not recommended to mix these two species, especially for beginner fish keepers. If you do choose to keep them together, it is important to have a backup plan, such as a separate tank, in case aggression occurs.

The size of the tank and the presence of hiding spots can also impact the likelihood of aggression. A larger tank with increased plant cover can provide separate territories and reduce stress for both species. However, even with these measures, there is still a risk of fighting and injury.

Overall, while it may be possible for Siamese fighting fish and guppies to coexist in the same tank, it is not advisable, especially if the guppies have long, flowing tails that resemble those of fighting fish. The potential for aggression and injury is high, and the safety and well-being of both species should always be the top priority.

Siamese fighting fish should not share a tank with other male fighting fish or female fighting fish they are not breeding with

Siamese fighting fish, also known as betta, are highly territorial and aggressive. Male Siamese fighting fish will fight to protect their territory and will attack each other if housed in the same tank. Female bettas can also become territorial and aggressive towards one another in confined spaces. Therefore, it is recommended to keep male and female Siamese fighting fish in separate tanks unless they are being bred.

Male Siamese fighting fish should not be placed in the same tank as they will fight to protect their territory. This aggression is due to their territorial nature and can result in the death of one or both fish. While some male bettas may coexist without aggression, it is not worth the risk of housing them together. It is best to provide each male betta with its own tank and territory to avoid any potential conflict.

Female Siamese fighting fish are generally more peaceful than males and can sometimes be kept together without issues. However, they still have the potential to be aggressive towards each other, especially in smaller tanks or confined spaces. If you choose to keep female bettas together, it is important to have a backup tank in case separation is needed due to aggression.

Male and female Siamese fighting fish should not be housed together unless it is for breeding purposes. Even during breeding, they may become aggressive towards each other before or after the process. Breeding Siamese fighting fish requires a lot of time, experience, and resources as many tanks are needed for the fry, which will eventually fight among themselves.

In conclusion, it is best to keep male Siamese fighting fish in individual tanks to avoid territorial aggression. Female bettas may be kept together, but a backup tank is advisable in case of aggression. Male and female Siamese fighting fish should only be housed together for breeding, and even then, close supervision is necessary to ensure their safety.

Siamese fighting fish can sometimes be kept with small, peaceful fish

Siamese fighting fish, or Bettas, are known for their aggressive tendencies and territoriality. Male Bettas, in particular, are often hostile towards other male Bettas, so it is not recommended to keep two males in the same tank.

However, despite their reputation, it is possible to keep Siamese fighting fish with certain other species of fish. Bettas can be kept with female Bettas, though even then, they may become aggressive with each other. If you are a beginner fish keeper, it is not recommended to attempt to house male Bettas with other types of fish.

That being said, Siamese fighting fish can sometimes be kept with small, peaceful fish. Some recommended tank mates include catfish, such as corydoras or otoclinus catfish, and small non-nippy tetras (though Widows, Suprae, and Cochus Blue tetras are not recommended). Bettas can also be kept with snails, such as mystery snails or nerite snails, and certain types of shrimp, like ghost shrimp or red cherry shrimp. It is important to note that smaller shrimp may be eaten by Bettas.

When keeping Bettas with other fish, it is crucial to have a backup tank in case aggression becomes an issue and separation is needed. Additionally, increased plant cover is advised to reduce stress by providing separate territories and hiding places. A larger tank is also beneficial, with a minimum capacity of 40 litres for one Siamese fighting fish and a school of small community fish, and an extra 20 litres for a large shoal or each additional small shoal of another species.

While it is possible to keep Siamese fighting fish with certain small, peaceful fish, it is important to carefully consider the temperament of the Betta and the specific needs of the other fish species. The behaviour and swimming patterns of the community fish are also important factors, as Bettas tend to claim the upper sections of the tank, so tank mates that swim at different levels can help reduce potential conflict.

Frequently asked questions